Action !
Before Babylon became a symbol of decadence and collapse, it was one of the ancient world’s most powerful cities. Its name later accumulated meanings beyond the historical city itself: wealth, spectacle, appetite, corruption, and a civilization approaching its fall.
Damien Chazelle could hardly have chosen a more appropriate name for his vision of early Hollywood.
Babylon begins in 1926, near the end of the silent-film era, and follows its characters through the arrival of synchronized sound. It is a period of extraordinary creation and sudden extinction. New stars rise overnight. Established stars discover that the industry they helped build no longer needs them. Technology advances, but human beings are discarded along the way.
Chazelle described the transition to sound as a transformation that effectively wiped one version of Hollywood away and built another on its remains. His film treats that change less like ordinary progress than a natural disaster sweeping through an unstable city.
Babylon is therefore both a love letter to cinema and an accusation against the machinery that produces it.
It applauds the people who gave their bodies, identities, dreams, and sometimes their lives to movies.
Then it asks whether the beauty on the screen was worth the destruction behind it.
The Most Magical Place in the World
The opening party announces the film’s intentions with almost comic aggression.
Music, sex, drugs, ambition, bodily fluids, and desperate social climbing collide inside a mansion packed with people trying to enter the movies—or remain inside them for one more night.
The excess is grotesque, but it is not random. Chazelle turns Hollywood into a city celebrating at the edge of an approaching catastrophe. Everyone is dancing, though the world that made their pleasure possible is already beginning to disappear.
The following day, the film offers a different kind of chaos.
Several productions unfold simultaneously across an outdoor filming ground. A medieval battle, romantic melodrama, explosions, drunken extras, exhausted crews, and an inexperienced actress discovering the camera all exist beside one another. The process is reckless and barely controlled, yet something beautiful emerges from it.
Manny Torres looks at this disorder and calls it the most magical place in the world.
He is not entirely wrong.
Cinema appears here as collective madness organized for a fraction of a second. Hundreds of workers perform separate tasks so that one face, gesture, landscape, or movement may survive on film. Chazelle’s production drew upon the rapid and often improvised working conditions of early Hollywood, when studios produced films at a remarkable pace and multiple units could shoot across shared lots and outdoor locations. The period was less orderly than the later studio system would make it appear, though the film deliberately exaggerates that disorder into myth.
The magic is genuine.
So is the exploitation.
That contradiction defines the film.
Too Many Toppings
Nellie LaRoy gives Babylon its clearest metaphor when she complains about people putting toppings on ice cream.
Ice cream is already good, she argues. Adding more only ruins it.
Nellie is talking about food, but she is also talking about herself.
She arrives in Hollywood without permission and becomes a star because the camera recognizes something immediate in her. She is vulgar, impulsive, wounded, funny, erotic, and uncontrollable. Her talent does not come from discipline or social refinement. It comes from the same disorder threatening to destroy her.
Hollywood celebrates that quality until the industry changes.
Once sound arrives, Nellie’s voice, accent, behavior, clothing, and public image become problems to correct. The studios want to preserve the energy that made her famous while removing everything that makes that energy hers.
They begin adding toppings.
Speak differently.
Dress correctly.
Attend the proper parties.
Become respectable.
Remain exciting.
Manny initially loves Nellie because she appears impossible to contain. But as he rises through the industry, he starts participating in the effort to contain her. The young man who once wanted only to be part of movies becomes an executive who reshapes people into products.
Nellie is not the only person who receives this treatment.
Trumpeter Sidney Palmer is valued for his music but humiliated when the studio decides his skin does not appear dark enough beside the other Black musicians on film. Manny asks him to apply darker makeup so the image will satisfy the camera and its imagined audience.
The request exposes the cruelty behind the industrial language of practicality. Hollywood claims to welcome Sidney’s talent while demanding that he alter his racial identity for the product.
Nellie must become more refined.
Sidney must be made darker.
Jack Conrad must change his voice, performance style, and relationship with the camera.
The industry accepts people only after deciding what should be added, removed, or disguised.
Manny believes he is helping them survive.
In reality, he has become the person placing toppings on the ice cream.
Art for People on the Ground
Jack Conrad is already a king when the film begins.
He is a silent-screen idol whose face carries desire, nobility, and adventure to millions. Beneath his vanity, however, lies a sincere belief in cinema.
Jack understands that movies have been dismissed as cheap entertainment. Theater and opera possess cultural prestige; vaudeville stages and nickelodeons belong to ordinary people.
A nickelodeon was an early storefront cinema that commonly charged five cents for admission, while vaudeville presented affordable mixed bills of comedy, music, dance, and novelty acts to mass audiences. These forms helped build an entertainment culture accessible to people who lacked the money or social education associated with elite theater.
Jack’s defense of movies is therefore not only artistic.
It is democratic.
What happens on the screen matters because a gas-station worker can enter a theater and feel less alone. Cinema does not require its audience to speak the language of cultural authority. A silent face can cross borders that spoken language cannot.
Jack jokes that love does not speak English either.
But sound changes the terms of his art.
The technology does not merely give cinema a voice. It creates new standards of acting, production, class, accent, and acceptable identity. Some artists adapt. Others become evidence of an embarrassing past the industry wishes to forget.
Jack’s deepest tragedy is not that movies die.
Movies survive.
They survive without him.
He spent his life defending cinema as meaningful art, only to discover that the art can remain immortal while the artist becomes obsolete.
The People in the Light and the People in the Dark
Elinor St. John explains Hollywood through the image of a burning house.
People die in the fire.
Cockroaches survive because they understand that the house never needed them. They crawl into the darkness, remain unseen, and wait.
Stars make the opposite mistake. They stand in the spotlight and begin to believe the house cannot exist without them.
Jack understands the lesson too late.
He has become inseparable from an art form that has already moved beyond him. Unable to accept life outside the light, he chooses his own ending.
Nellie’s disappearance is different.
She does not calmly decide to die. She rejects Manny’s attempt to rescue and remake her, dances into the night, and continues living at a speed she cannot survive. The film later records her death from an overdose at thirty-four. She does not choose death in the same manner as Jack, but she refuses the version of survival Manny offers.
Jack knowingly leaves the burning house.
Nellie dances until the fire consumes her.
Manny crawls into the dark.
He begs for his life, abandons Los Angeles, and survives. That survival can appear shameful, but it also makes him the film’s witness. Decades later, he is the only central figure able to return and see what all that suffering produced.
He enters a theater showing Singin’ in the Rain.
The 1952 musical famously transforms Hollywood’s transition from silent pictures to sound into exuberant comedy. Babylon looks behind that polished memory and imagines the panic, humiliation, technical misery, and human casualties that the musical converted into entertainment. The two films even share parallel sound-production disasters, while Chazelle makes the connection explicit by placing Manny before Singin’ in the Rain in the final sequence.
If Singin’ in the Rain remembers the birth of sound as a joyful musical, Babylon asks who disappeared in the darkness to create that joy.
The Beautiful Thing Made From Something Terrible
The final montage races through cinema history.
Silent images give way to sound, color, widescreen spectacle, digital effects, abstract flashes, and films not yet imaginable to the characters who died during the first transition.
The film condemns Hollywood’s appetite while surrendering to spectacle.
It mourns exploitation through one of the most extravagant studio productions imaginable.
It argues that movies destroy people, then uses the beauty of movies to make that destruction feel transcendent.
That is not necessarily hypocrisy.
It is the paradox at the center of cinema.
Images can outlive the conditions that produced them. An actor’s pain may vanish from public memory while the expression captured on film remains. Crews disappear from history, but the light they arranged continues reaching audiences born generations later.
Jack is gone.
Nellie is gone.
Sidney leaves.
Manny survives but loses the world he once loved.
The industry continues.
The film continues.
Hollywood destroys the people who make movies, then turns what remains of them into light.
The people disappear.
The light reaches the screen.
Post a Comment