"When faith loses its way, what remains to guide us?"
Robert Eggers's The Witch is often introduced as a horror film about witches, Satan, and Puritan paranoia.
It is all of those things.
But after the credits rolled, I found myself thinking about something much simpler.
This is not a story about people losing faith in God.
It is a story about a family who slowly loses faith in one another.
The witch may be real.
The Devil may be real.
Yet the greatest tragedy arrives long before either of them wins.
It begins the moment a father trusts an invisible God more than the daughter standing in front of him.
Released in 2015, The Witch is set in 1630s New England, where an English Puritan family is banished from its plantation after William refuses to submit to the authority of his religious community. Writer-director Robert Eggers built the screenplay from period journals, court records, and Puritan writings, giving the film a remarkable sense of historical authenticity. Even its dialogue draws heavily from seventeenth-century English.
That authenticity is what makes the horror so unsettling.
The supernatural may belong to folklore.
The fear feels painfully human.
A Family That Walks Away from Safety
William believes he is protecting his family.
He leaves the plantation because he believes the community has drifted away from true faith.
At first, this looks admirable.
A man chooses conviction over comfort.
But as the story unfolds, another possibility emerges.
William mistakes his own pride for righteousness.
He cannot hunt well.
He cannot farm successfully.
He secretly sells Katherine's silver cup.
He cannot provide food for his children.
Yet he never questions his own authority.
Instead, every failure becomes another spiritual test.
The family's survival depends on him.
His certainty depends only on himself.
Those are not the same thing.
Thomasin Never Stops Believing
One of the film's greatest ironies is that Thomasin begins as one of its most devout characters.
She prays.
She obeys.
She worries about sin.
She fears eternal damnation.
Nothing about her suggests rebellion.
Yet faith alone cannot save her from suspicion.
After baby Samuel disappears, every unexplained event quietly moves suspicion toward Thomasin.
The missing child.
The failed harvest.
Caleb's strange behavior.
The sick livestock.
Eventually, Thomasin herself.
No one sees her becoming a witch.
Instead, everyone slowly decides she must already be one.
That distinction matters.
Before Thomasin ever signs the Devil's book...
her family has already judged her.
They Believe in God...
But Not in Their Daughter
The film's central contradiction appears through William.
He believes completely in God.
He believes in Satan.
He believes in witches.
He believes evil hides inside the forest.
Yet he cannot believe the frightened girl standing before him.
This is the tragedy that stayed with me.
William trusts the invisible.
He doubts the visible.
He demands faith from everyone else while refusing to place any faith in the people closest to him.
Perhaps The Witch is asking a painful question.
What happens when religion remains...
but compassion disappears?
Faith without trust becomes fear.
Faith without love becomes accusation.
Faith without humility becomes pride wearing God's voice.
That, to me, is far more terrifying than any witch.
Caleb and the Fear of Desire
Caleb's death is among the film's most disturbing moments.
His attraction toward Thomasin is subtle but unmistakable.
His curiosity leads him into the woods.
There he encounters the witch, whose beauty masks unimaginable horror.
When Caleb returns home, he dies in ecstatic religious delirium.
The scene refuses simple interpretation.
Is he saved?
Is he damned?
Has he encountered God...
or simply another form of temptation?
Harvey Scrimshaw's extraordinary performance never answers those questions.
Instead, it allows faith, guilt, sexuality, and terror to collapse into one unbearable experience.
In The Witch, spiritual ecstasy and horror sometimes wear the same face.
The Witch Is Real...
But So Is the Family's Failure
One reason The Witch remains so powerful is that it never forces the audience to choose between psychological horror and supernatural horror.
The witch exists.
Black Phillip exists.
The Devil exists.
The evil is real.
Yet evil enters a family that is already breaking apart.
Samuel's disappearance is not what destroys them.
It merely exposes cracks that already existed.
William's pride.
Katherine's grief.
Caleb's shame.
The twins' childish fascination.
Thomasin's isolation.
The Devil does not invent these weaknesses.
He finds them.
"Wouldst Thou Like to Live Deliciously?"
Few endings in modern horror are more unforgettable.
After everyone she loves has died, Thomasin is left completely alone.
Only then does Black Phillip finally speak.
His offer is surprisingly small.
Butter.
Beautiful dresses.
Freedom.
The chance to see the world.
And one simple request.
Sign your name.
Many viewers read this as liberation.
Others see only damnation.
I think the ending is more complicated than either interpretation.
Thomasin does become free.
She also loses everything that once defined her.
Family.
Home.
Faith.
Childhood.
She gains agency only after the world has taken every other choice away.
Is that freedom?
Or merely another prison disguised as liberation?
Eggers deliberately refuses to answer.
The Last Smile
The final image often feels triumphant.
Thomasin removes her clothes.
She joins the witches.
She rises into the night sky laughing.
It looks like freedom.
But it is impossible to forget everything required to reach that moment.
Every member of her family is dead.
Every human relationship has collapsed.
The community rejected them.
Her parents doubted her.
The Devil simply arrived last.
Perhaps Thomasin finally becomes herself.
Or perhaps the only identity left available to her is the one everyone else had already chosen.
A witch.
The ending never tells us which is true.
That uncertainty is exactly why it lingers.
Post a Comment